Response to Comment on “On the Evolution Equations of Nonlinearly Permissible, Coherent Hole Structures Propagating Persistently in Collisionless Plasmas” Ann. Phys. (Berlin) 2023, 2300102

Titelangaben

Schamel, Hans ; Chakrabarti, Nikhil:
Response to Comment on “On the Evolution Equations of Nonlinearly Permissible, Coherent Hole Structures Propagating Persistently in Collisionless Plasmas” Ann. Phys. (Berlin) 2023, 2300102.
In: Annalen der Physik. (20 Dezember 2023) . - 2300441.
ISSN 1521-3889
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/andp.202300441

Volltext

Link zum Volltext (externe URL):

Abstract

Abstract Our critical analysis of Hutchinson's work, expressed in our recent article in the Annalen der Physik, which goes beyond mutual misunderstandings and misrepresentations, is also maintained in light of his Comment. The main reason for the limited yield in structural description is the author's adherence to the BGK method and the associated lack of a nonlinear dispersion relation (NDR). Even with an additional asymptotic constraint, as a supposed replacement for the NDR, the author's theory remains inferior to the pseudo-potential method.